2. Articles of charge to be drawn out for public
inquiry into conduct of certain public servants.
3. Authorities to whom inquiry may be committed — Notice
to accused.
4. Conduct of Government prosecution.
6.
Security from accuser left by Government to prosecute.
7. Power of Government to abandon prosecution and to
allow accuser to continue it.
9. Penalty for disobedience to process.
10. Copy of charge and list to be furnished to
accused.
11. Procedure at beginning of inquiry —
Non-appearance of accused and admission of charge.
12. Prosecutor's right of address.
13. Evidence for prosecution and examination of
witnesses — Re-examination by prosecutor.
14. Power to admit or call for new evidence or
prosecution — Accused's right to adjournment.
15. Defence of accused — To be recorded only when
written.
16. Evidence for defence and examination of witnesses.
17. Examination of witnesses and evidence by
prosecutor.
21. Report of Commissioners' proceedings.
23. Definition of “Government”.
24. Saving of enactments as to dismissal of certain
officers — Commission under Act for their trial.
25. Saving of power of removal without inquiry under
Act.
___________
For regulating inquiries into the
behaviour of public servants.
Whereas
it is expedient to amend the law for regulating inquiries into the behaviour of
public servants not removable from their appointments without the sanction of
Government and to make the same uniform throughout India; It is enacted as
follows: —
STATE AMENDMENT
Bihar
In the preamble, omit the words “not
removable from their appointments without the sanction of Government, and to
make the same uniform throughout India.”
[Bihar Act
34 of 1951].
1. Repeal
of Acts. [Repealed by the Repealing Act, 1870 (14 of 1870), Section 1 and
Schedule, Part II].
2.
Articles of charge to be drawn out for public inquiry into conduct of certain
public servants. — Whenever the Government shall be of opinion
that there are good grounds for making a formal and public inquiry into the
truth of any imputation of misbehaviour by any person in the service of the
Government, not removable from his appointment without the sanction of the
Government, it may cause the substance of the imputations to be drawn into
distinct articles of charge, and may order a formal and public inquiry to be
made into the truth thereof.
STATE AMENDMENT
Bihar
In Section 2, omit the words “not removable
from his appointment without the sanction of the Government.”
[Bihar Act
34 of 1951].
3.
Authorities to whom inquiry may be committed — Notice to accused. — The inquiry may be committed
either to the Court, Board or other Authority to which the person accused is
subordinate or to any other person or persons, to be specially appointed by the
Government, Commissioners for the purpose: notice of which commission shall be
given to the person accused ten days at least before the beginning of the
inquiry.
STATE AMENDMENT
Bihar
In Section 3, omit the words “Court, Board
or other”.
[Bihar Act
34 of 1951].
4.
Conduct of Government prosecution. — When the Government shall think fit to
conduct the prosecution, it shall nominate some person to conduct the same on
its behalf.
5. Charge
by accuser to be written and verified — Penalty for false accusation — Institution of inquiry by Government. —
When the charge shall be brought by an accuser, the Government shall require
the accusation to be reduced to writing, and verified by the oath or solemn
affirmation of the accuser; and every person who shall wilfully and maliciously
make any false accusation under this Act, upon such oath or affirmation, shall
be liable to the penalties of perjury; but this enactment shall not be
construed to prevent the Government from instituting any inquiry which it shall
think fit, without such accusation on oath or solemn affirmation as aforesaid.
6.
Security from accuser left by Government to prosecute. — Where the imputations
shall have been made by an accuser, and the Government shall think fit to leave
to him the conduct of the prosecution, the Government before appointing the
commission shall require him to furnish reasonable security that he will attend
and prosecute the charge thoroughly and effectually, and also will be
forthcoming to answer any counter- charge or action which may be afterwards
brought against him for malicious prosecution or perjury or subornation of
perjury, as the case may be.
7. Power
of Government to abandon prosecution and to allow accuser to continue it. — At any
subsequent stage of the proceedings, the Government may, if it think fit,
abandon the prosecution, and in such case, may, if it think fit, on the
application of the accuser, allow him to continue the prosecution, if he is
desirous of so doing, on his furnishing such security as is hereinbefore
mentioned.
8. Powers
of commissioners — Their
protection — Service of their process — Powers of Court, etc., acting under
commission. — The commissioners shall have the same power of punishing
contempts and obstructions to their proceedings, as is given to Civil and
Criminal Courts by the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898 (5 of 1989) and shall
have the same powers for the summons of witnesses, and for compelling the
production of documents, and for the discharge of their duty under the
commission, and shall be entitled to the same protection as the Zila and City
Judges, except that all process to cause the attendance of witnesses or other
compulsory process, shall be served through and executed by the Zila or City
Judge in whose jurisdiction the witness or other person resides, on whom the
process is to be served, and if he resides within Calcutta, Madras or Bombay,
then through the Supreme Court of Judicature thereto. When the commission has
been issued to a Court, or other person or persons having power to issue such
process in the exercise of their ordinary authority, they may also use all such
power for the purposes of the commission.
STATE AMENDMENT
Maharashtra
In Section 8 for the word “Bombay”
substitute “Greater Bombay”
[Bom. Act
17 of 1945].
9.
Penalty for disobedience to process. — All persons disobeying any
lawful process issued as aforesaid for the purposes of the commission shall be
liable to the same penalties as if the same had issued originally from the
Court or other authority through whom it is executed.
10. Copy
of charge and list to be furnished to accused. — A copy of
the articles of charge, and list of the documents and witnesses by which each
charge is to be sustained, shall be delivered to the person accused, at least
three days before the beginning of the inquiry, exclusive of the day of
delivery and the first day of the inquiry.
11.
Procedure at beginning of inquiry — Non-appearance
of accused and admission of charge. —
At the beginning of the inquiry the prosecutor shall exhibit the
articles of charge to the Commissioners, which shall be openly read, and the
person accused shall, thereupon be required to plead “guilty” or “not guilty”
to each of them, which pleas shall be forthwith recorded with the articles of
charge. If the person accused refuses, or without reasonable cause neglects, to
appear to answer the charge either personally or by his counsel or agent, he shall
be taken to admit the truth of the articles of charge.
12.
Prosecutor's right of address. — The prosecutor shall then be entitled to
address the commissioners in explanation of the articles of charge, and of the
evidence by which they are to be proved : his address shall not be recorded.
13.
Evidence for prosecution and examination of witnesses — Re-examination by prosecutor. — The oral and
documentary evidence for the prosecution shall then be exhibited; the witnesses
shall be examined by or on behalf of the prosecutor and may be cross-examined
by or on behalf of the person accused. The prosecutor shall be entitled to
re-examine the witnesses on any points on which they have been cross-examined,
but not on any new matter, without leave of the commissioners, who also may put
such questions as they think fit.
14. Power
to admit or call for new evidence or prosecution — Accused's right to adjournment. — If it shall
appear necessary before the close of the case for the prosecution, the
commissioners may, in their discretion, allow the prosecutor to exhibit
evidence not included in the list given to the person accused, or may
themselves call for new evidence; and in such case the person accused shall be
entitled to have, if he demand it, an adjournment of the proceedings for three
clear days, before the exhibition of such new evidence exclusive of the day of
adjournment and of the day of which the proceedings are adjourned.
15.
Defence of accused — To be
recorded only when written. — When the case for the prosecution is closed, the
person accused shall be required to make his defence, orally or in writing, as
he shall prefer. If made orally, it shall not be recorded; if made in writing,
it shall be recorded, after being openly read, and in that case a copy shall be
given at the same time to the prosecutor.
16.
Evidence for defence and examination of witnesses. — The
evidence for the defence shall then be exhibited, and the witnesses examined,
who shall be liable to cross- examination and re-examination and to examination
by the commissioners according to the like rules and the witnesses for the
prosecution.
17.
Examination of witnesses and evidence by prosecutor. — [Repealed
by the Repealing Act, 1876 (12 of 1876), Section 2 and Schedule, Part I.]
18. Notes
of oral evidence. — The commissioners or some person appointed by
them shall take notes in English of all oral evidence which shall be read aloud
to each witness by whom the same was given, and, if necessary, explained to him
in the language in which it was given, and shall be recorded with the
proceedings.
19.
Inquiry when closed with defence — Prosecutor
when entitled to reply and give evidence — Accused not entitled to adjournment.
— If the person accused makes only an oral defence, and exhibits no evidence,
the inquiry shall end with his defence; if he records a written defence, or
exhibits evidence, the prosecutor shall be entitled to a general oral reply on
the whole case, and may also exhibit evidence to contradict any evidence
exhibited for the defence, in which case the person accused shall not be
entitled to any adjournment of the proceedings, although such new evidence were
not included in the list furnished to him.
20. Power
to require amendment of charge and to adjourn — Reason for refusing adjournment to be recorded. —
When the commissioners shall be of opinion that the articles of charge, or any
of them, are not drawn with sufficient clearness and precision the
commissioners may, in their discretion, require the same to be amended, and may
thereupon, on the application of the person accused, adjourn the inquiry for a
reasonable time. The commissioners may also, if they think fit, adjourn the
inquiry from time to time, on the application of either the prosecutor or the
person accused, on the ground of sickness or unavoidable absence of any witness
or other reasonable cause. When such application is made and refused, the
commissioners shall record the application, and their reasons for refusing to
comply with it.
21. Report of Commissioners' proceedings. — After the
close of the inquiry the commissioners shall forthwith report to Government
their proceedings under the commission, and shall send with the record thereof
their opinion upon each of the articles of charge separately, with such
observations as they think fit on the whole case.
22. Power
to call for further evidence or explanation — Inquiry into additional articles of charge —
Reference of report of Special Commissioners' final orders. — The Government, on consideration of the
report of the Commissioners' may order them to take further evidence to give
further explanation of their opinions. It may also order additional articles of
charge to be framed, in which case the inquiry into the truth of such additional
articles shall be made in the same manner as is herein directed with respect to
the original charges. When special commissioners have been appointed, the
Government may also, if it thinks fit, refer the report of the Commissioners to the Court or other authority to which the
person accused is subordinate, for their opinion on the case; and will finally
pass such orders thereon as appear just and consistent with its powers in such
cases.
STATE AMENDMENT
Bihar
(i)
Section 22 renumbered as sub-section (1) thereof and in the said sub-section so
renumbered —
(a) omit the words “Court or other”;
(b) after the words “pass such orders
thereon” insert the words “or direct the authority to which the person accused
is subordinate to pass such orders thereon.”
(ii)
Add the following sub-section (2) after the renumbered sub-section (1)
— “(2) Where the orders under
sub-section (1) are passed by any authority other than the Government, the
Government shall always have the power to review the orders and pass such
orders as appear to it to be just and proper.”
[Bihar Act
34 of 1951].
23.
Definition of “Government”. — In the Act, “the Government” means the
Central Government in the case of persons employed under that Government and
the State Government in the case of persons employed under that Government.
24.
Saving of enactments as to dismissal of certain officers — Commission under Act for their trial. — Nothing in
this Act shall be construed to repeal any Act or Regulation in force for the
suspension or dismissal of Principal and other Sadr Amins or of Deputy
Magistrate or Deputy Collectors, but a commission may be issued for the trial
of any charge against any of the said
officers, under this Act, in any case in which the Government shall think it
expedient.
25.
Saving of power of removal without inquiry under Act. — Nothing in
this Act shall be construed to affect the authority of Government for
suspending or removing any public servant for any cause without an inquiry
under this Act.
STATE AMENDMENT
Bihar
For Section 25, substitute the following: —
“25 Saving of power of removal without inquiry under Act. — Nothing in this Act shall be construed to affect
the power of the Government or the authority to which the person accused is
subordinate to suspend or remove any public servant for any cause without an
enquiry under this Act.”
[Bihar Act
34 of 1951.]
________________